The “resolution” column will show the outcome of the committee’s deliberations, once added by the chair/Speech Advisor.
Number of records to review: 13
Serial | 07* |
---|---|
Date Updated | 05/05/2023 |
Category | Play Acting |
Contestant Name(s) | Dakota Bares, Emily Frizzell, Charlie O'Connor, Aubree Shroda |
Nature of Concern |
|
Describe concern | The adjudicator deducted a point under ‘Conveying Meaning’ which her comments indicate was for the content of the piece, not the presentation of it. In the Rules & Policies section of the High School Speech Handbook, 2022-2023, regulation 6.1.2 (Quality Literary Material) states “In some categories (Farrago and Solo Acting), the selection of material is a criterion for evaluation.” This piece in question was in the Play Acting category and therefore should not lose a point for the content of the material. Although she used words contained in the criterion description, she actually states that the possibility of the material being “offensive…this made the characters less believable,” showing that her evaluation of the piece material was the basis for downgrading the work. |
What adjudicator specifically wrote or did | Under “Conveying Meaning” she wrote: “Be aware of the stereotypes in your piece. It can be considered offensive and this made the characters less believable. The repeat could be considered the climax-well done.” Although she used words contained in the criterion description, she actually states that the possibility of the material being “offensive…this made the characters less believable,” showing that her evaluation of the piece material was the basis for downgrading the work. |
Evaluation Sheet(s) | 128H1-Play-Acting-Evaluation-Sheet.pdf |
Round/Time | 9:30 am Sat |
Committee Review | |
Initial Advisor Comments | We did resolve this issue on Saturday and restored point. This concern should be deleted or completed by stating that decision was already delivered. |
Resolution: | Upheld |
Disposition | The committee addressed during the festival and already restored a point. |
Result Number | 0 |