The “resolution” column will show the outcome of the committee’s deliberations, once added by the chair/Speech Advisor.
Number of records to review: 13
Serial | 02 |
---|---|
Date Updated | 05/05/2023 |
Category | Informative Speech |
Contestant Name(s) | Reese Ammon |
Nature of Concern |
|
Describe concern | It feels that she took points off due to a lack of knowledge of the topic as opposed to the speech itself. |
What adjudicator specifically wrote or did | Specific comments: Prevented players from _______ the hall of fame, I think a word is missing here. The problem we have with the above critique is that a word is not missing and this resulted in a deducted point. |
Evaluation Sheet(s) | |
Round/Time | 5:30 PM |
Committee Review | |
Initial Advisor Comments | I am not clear what to do here. I am unsure if adjudicator missed a word herself? Therefore, why deduct point. |
Resolution: | Denied |
Disposition | The Referee Committee feels that the adjudicator stated a word was missing and that there was some sort of break in fluency. The committee was not there to hear the presentation. The adjudicator did list a reason for a point deduction. |
Result Number | 0 |